Tuesday, December 16, 2008
Welcome to the Liquidity Trap
Somehow markets view a historically low fed-funds rate, and a dramatic shift in the primary monetary policy instrument as a sign to celebrate rather than as a signal that the economy is in a very bad place and will be there for long time- Dow up 360; S&P up 45; TSX up 262.
Monday, December 15, 2008
Revised BC Forecast
1) Canada is almost certainly going to be in a recession to start 2009. If standard models for the transmission of US shocks to the Canadian economy hold, a 4%-6% decline in US growth could translate to 1.2%-1.8% decline in Canada - on top of softening domestic demand. These shocks should hit BC through inter-provincial and US export channels.
2) According to BC Stats, inter-provincial exports account for about 16% of BC GDP, with most of the trade occurring with Ontario and Alberta. In the 1990 recession, BC exports declined about 2% and in the 1982 recession exports declined close to 11%.
3) International exports account for 28% of BC GDP. In the last US recession, these exports fell 5%. Moreover, key BC export sectors - mining and forestry - are in serious trouble.
This all sounds really awful - perhaps too awful to produce 1.3-1.4% growth. Taking the above into consideration, my revised forecast says that without VANOC stimulus, the BC economy would likely slip into a recession, posting growth of -0.2%. With VANOC spending, and its indirect effects, growth should be bumped up by 0.4%-0.5%.
Therefore, the revised forecast is 0.2-0.3% - 2010 saves the day! (just kidding, no hate mail please).
Firing Blanks
Given that most of the normal channels through which monetary policy works (eg. housing, credit, investment) are either severely jammed or completely broken - there will likely be no material stimulative impact from a rate cut. Moreover, the effective funds rate has been trading at below 50bps for quite some time, and it is still unclear how the decision to pay interest on reserves has impacted the usefulness of the fed-funds rate as a policy instrument (see here for an excellent discussion).

There also may be significant risks to cutting rates , most prominent, (as Tim Duy notes) of which is a disorderly adjustment in the US dollar. A falling dollar, along with massive borrowing associated with bailouts and a coming stimulus package, could send interest rates higher as countries demand higher compensation on US government debt (though this hasn't happened in the past couple of years, despite a weaker dollar and massive borrowing). Moreover, as global trade deteriorates, there may be none of the typical stimulative trade effects normally associated with currency depreciation.
What are the risks if they don't cut? Who knows. Uncertainty is scary and markets are too fragile not to deliver on expectations which is why the Fed will continue towards the zero bound with their hands firmly gripping the monetary spigot.
Wednesday, December 10, 2008
Dr. Taylor’s Monetary Tonic
r =r* + β(π- π*) + γ(y – y*), where values with a *are steady-state or target values.
Even though the Bank of Canada is mandated solely to keep inflation near its target of 2%, it is not surprising that it responds to an output gap as well since an economy growing above potential is inflationary. An estimated rule reveals weights on the inflation and output gap of 1.88 and 0.38 – awfully close to the values of 2 and 0.5 suggested here: http://www.bankofcanada.ca/en/res/wp/2002/wp02-1.pdf. These estimates show a much heavier weight on excess inflation than on output, about what we should expect from an inflation targeting central bank.
Taylor rule for the target rate tracks the average quarterly overnight rate fairly closely, though suggests that the Bank should have started cutting earlier and more aggressively
UPDATE- Nick Rowe asks where the broken line comes from in the above graph - It represents my forecast (guess) at the future path of the output gap and inflation. Needless to say, i'm expecting inflation to not be a problem and for growth to disappoint to the downside. I've also added a second red broken line to show the Taylor rule path for the overnight rate based on the current BoC forecast (MP from Oct. 23). Thanks Nick.
r = r* + β(π- π*) + γ(y – y*), where values with a * are steady-state or target values.
Even though the Bank of Canada is mandated solely to keep inflation near its target of 2%, it is not surprising that it responds to an output gap as well since an economy growing above potential is inflationary. An estimated
A
Tuesday, December 9, 2008
Onward to the zero bound!

Wow. 75 basis points! I'm not sure whether to read this as the BoC trying to get ahead of the curve or if Marc Carney and Co. are seeing some really bad data on the horizon.
from the press release:
While Canada's economy evolved largely as expected during the summer and early autumn, it is now entering a recession as a result of the weakness in global economic activity. The recent declines in terms of trade, real income growth, and confidence are prompting more cautious behaviour by households and businesses.
It will be interesting to see the forecast revisions in the Monetary Policy Update in January.
Sunday, December 7, 2008
A Modest Proposal for Statistics Canada
I have a problem with Statistics Canada. I’ve been known to curse the awful labyrinth that is CANSIM but nothing fills the swear jar quite like having to PAY for data.
Now, I know that some readers of this blog will have old grad school friends who work at Stats Can, and I don’t mean to insult them. I know StatsCan has a great reputation internationally, and I’ve worked enough with international data enough to attest to the quality of StatsCan’s work.
My firm doesn’t use enough data to justify paying Haver Analytics or the Conference Board or another data provider for an annual subscription. Therefore, when I need data, not only do I have to go through roughly 6000 confirmation screens before getting it, I have to pay the ridiculous sum of $3 per series. That is, if I want a time-series of the unemployment rate by province and the national rate, I have to pay $33. If I want to add employment numbers, the participation rate or any other series – it quickly adds up. Sure I can expense these costs, and yes I could build my own database and update it each month as data comes out, but I shouldn’t have to. If I want the same data from the
So, a modest proposal for StatsCan – Carve out a core set of macroeconomic data and post it free of charge. Use the FRED II database as a guide. I don’t know how expensive this would be, and I know that an organization that hasn’t laid anyone off since Joe Clark was Prime Minister isn’t especially adept at cutting cots – but please find a way.
End rant – back to economics a little later.
Short and Mild?

Is it likely that a Canadian recession will be only slightly worse than the 2001 slowdown given a protracted and painful recession in the economy of its largest trading partner? I'll call it now - Bay Street will be revising its forecasts substantially downward in the next couple of months.
